‘Devil is in detail’ in new milk price deal (From Witney Gazette)
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
‘Devil is in detail’ in new milk price deal
7:00am Wednesday 25th July 2012 in News
By Freddie Whittaker, covering Politics and Kidlington. Call me on 01865 425498
Buy this photo »
Chris White, left, is pictured with his father, dairy farmer Reuben White, and some of their herd at Cheers Farm
A DEAL between dairy producers and milk processing companies “needs to be enforceable” according to county farmers.
Landowners have claimed a fall in the amount they are paid for milk by processors and unprecedented bad weather have put a strain on the county’s dairy farmers.
The amount farmers receive from processors is expected to fall from around 29p to just 25p per litre from August 1. As a litre of milk costs Oxfordshire farmers approximately 30p to produce., it means many are effectively operating at a loss.
The National Farmers’ Union and Dairy UK have agreed in principal to a “voluntary code of practice”, to be finalised over the summer, which could give farmers a greater say on the way milk prices are set. It would also mean supermarkets would have to give more notice when they plan on cutting the amount they pay for milk. But farmers still want the forthcoming cut reversed.
Geoff Ridgway, a dairy farmer from near Banbury and Farmers for Action member, said the devil of any deal would be in the detail.
He said: “Of course, I will welcome any deal which is good for the farmers.
“However, it will have to be something which is enforceable.
“We are at a crossroads as farmers. “We don’t want a fudge, we want something that’s positive to go forward, we don’t want to be fobbed off.”
Agreement in principal was reached on Monday, after the two sides met face-to-face at the Royal Welsh show in Powys.
The announcement came after landowners, tenants and campaigners said they would struggle with stock levels of food for cattle this winter.
Farmers produce milk that is bought by processors and then sold on to customers, including supermarkets.
Farmers the Oxford Mail has spoken to said it costs them 30p per litre to produce milk.
It is currently sold in Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Waitrose for 49p per pint, equivalent to around 85p per litre.
The Farmers for Action group said there were around a dozen dairy farmers in Oxfordshire.
Reuben White, from Cheers Farm near Abingdon, blamed the supermarkets for the situation.
He said: “The supermarkets have these dedicated groups of suppliers, so they can say they’re paying these wonderful prices, but nobody really knows how much of their milk they’re getting from these sources.
“Ian Potter, from Ian Potter Associates, has made estimates that it’s about 15 to 20 per cent coming from them, so the other 80 to 85 per cent is coming in through the back door at rock-bottom prices.”
He added that unprecedented bad weather was also harming the industry as farmers struggle to forage enough winter feed for their cattle. He said: “It’s potentially a very serious situation, more serious than the milk prices.”
NFU president Peter Kendall praised the decision from some supermarkets to increase the premium they pay.
He said: “We have started to see some positive moves by some retailers and this commitment to British dairy farmers is to be applauded.
“However, we now need to see all retailers and major buyers of milk stepping up to the plate.”
Last week, protests took place in Yorkshire, Leicestershire and the Robert Wiseman Dairy processing plant near Bridgwater, Somerset, which was blockaded by hundreds of farmers.
Comments(4)
Lady Penelopee
says...
9:18am Wed 25 Jul 12
It disgusts me the way supermarkets are taking advantage of dairy farmers.
The supermarket pay 29p for a litre of milk, which costs 30p to produce, then sell it for 85p.
If this carries on, then UK dairyfarms will all shut down, and our milk will end up coming from abroad!
Personally I would LOVE to boycott supermarket milk, and buy directly from a dairyfarmer for a fair price. Can this be done?
xjohnx
says...
11:07am Wed 25 Jul 12
If milk production drops, price will rise.
If milk supply rises, price will drop.
If your local garage owner said, I 'demand' a gauranteed income, regardless of market conditions, what would you say?.
Man on the Green
says...
11:57am Wed 25 Jul 12
Firstly, where are the 80% of "back door" ((sic) supplies coming from? And leading on from there:
1. How can these suppliers who are undercutting the established market manage to produce their milk at a profit?
2. Are they doing so in full compliance with sanitary conditions and what are their diary cattle fed on?
3. Could we have an indication of geographic origin on milk as we do on other products?
Secondly, how can the producers agree guaranteed prices with retailers without falling foul of anti-cartel rules?
Thirdly, what are Tory government ministers doing trying to fix prices? I thought they believed in a free market economy.
By all means let farmers use their collective bargaining power to get a fair deal (it sounds as if they're getting there, but having to face up to some uncomfortable truths in the process), and they have succeeded to a large degree in highlighting the way in which large profits are being creamed off (sorry!) along the way by intermediaries and processors. But please, let's keep government out of this! (Apart from anything else, they've shown themselves to be worse than useless at contract negotiation.)
xjohnx says...
8:55am Wed 25 Jul 12
Every other industry has to adapt to its markets.