Watchdog clears police over Kelly pictures (From Witney Gazette)
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
Watchdog clears police over Kelly pictures
11:00am Saturday 20th October 2012 in News
THE UK’s information watchdog has upheld Thames Valley Police’s decision not to release uncensored photographs relating to the death of weapons inspector Dr David Kelly.
The Information Commissioner’s Office said the release would cause “significant distress” to the family of the scientist, whose body was found in woods at Harrowdown Hill, near his Southmoor home in 2003.
A member of the public requested all “uncensored, un-redacted and complete” photographs relating to his death under the Freedom of Information Act.
The force said it would not release the images as the act exempts information used for investigations and information which would “endanger the physical or mental health of any individual”.
The unnamed woman who made the request branded this “preposterous” and demanded a “written statement from Dr Kelly’s brother that he does not want these photographs released to the public”. The force said there had “already been a very public examination of the circumstances surrounding Dr David Kelly’s death”. The 2003 Hutton Inquiry found the 59-year-old died from blood loss after cutting his wrist with a knife.
The Information Commissioner found that releasing the images would case “significant distress” and could not be outweighed by the public interest.
Comments(3)
benjamin
says...
2:16pm Sat 20 Oct 12
Carfax Cabby
says...
2:11am Sun 21 Oct 12
Peter Beswick says...
1:38pm Sat 20 Oct 12
Photos were taken in the morning when the ambulance crew were present; more were taken in the afternoon when the forensic team arrived.
Very different descriptions , of the scene, are given by the search team who found the body (body sat against a tree) and when the ambulance crew arrived (body lay flat on the ground, ambulance technician stood in gap between a tree and the head of the body when checking for signs of life.) More differing accounts are given by the forensic team and others.
Lord Hutton said he saw a photo showing the body with its head slumped against a tree. Dr Shepherd who assisted the Attorney General with his ad hoc investigation of Dr Kelly’s death said he saw a photo that showed the head of the body a “significant” distance from the tree.
If these two photographs exist it proves that there was third party activity at the scene which drives a coach and horses through the suicide conclusion.
The first police officer on the scene said at the Hutton inquiry that the body was lay flat when he first saw it, he has since admitted in a newspaper article that the body was slumped against a tree when he first saw it.
There is overwhelming evidence that the body was moved and other changes occurred at the scene between the morning and afternoon. The photos will prove this.
Thames Valley Police, Lord Hutton and the Attorney General could have shown the photos, during their investigations, to the witnesses that have given hugely varying accounts of what the saw, at different times and said “Was this the scene, was this the position of the body when you saw it?” All chose not to, all chose not to investigate the evidence. And then the photos were locked away for 70 years.
Until this matter is cleared up the Kelly family will gain no closure, the police, Lord Hutton and the Attorney General will, rightly, be suspected of cover up, the public’s confidence in the Justice System will remain tarnished.
There was then and remains now, no good reason why the morning and afternoon photos can’t be shown to eyewitnesses who actually saw the body and the very simple question asked “is this what you saw when you were present”.